Belenka Icon Review

Belenka Icon All Year shoes in Cognac
Injinji socks and Belenka Icon shoes

*Get 5% off your order with my code ANYASREVIEWS*

Belenka, a brand known for uncompromising barefoot qualities, has a lot up its sleeve for 2020. Besides revamping their classic styles, the Belenka team also has new designs and colors headed our way throughout the year (woot!). I had the opportunity to review their winter boots late last year, and am so glad I get to test out their new Icon shoe.

The Icon

The Icon All Year shoe is the updated version of their original All Year shoe. The new Icon has a rubber wall sole (same as in their winter boots) and a higher quality leather. Some other new features include thicker laces, metal eyelets, a padded collar, and a pull-tab at the back.

Most of the Icon shoes come in a smooth nubuck leather, but there is also a shiny black leather and 2 canvas options (black and brown). Besides those external changes, the new Belenka shoes fit exactly the same as the originals.

Materials

My cognac Icon shoes are made of brushed nubuck, and it is very soft and sturdy. On the leather versions the interior is lined with a natural leather, making these great shoes to wear barefoot. The shoe feels thick without being stiff and I anticipate it will hold its shape well as opposed to stretching out.

The outsole is a rubber/plastic blend that was adopted for its durability. I never tried their original line of shoes, so I can’t compare it to the old sole. But from my experience using the Belenka winter boots, I know this new one is very durable. Walled soles (where the outsole wraps up around the shoe) are great for preventing damage from scuffs or puddles and keep the shoe looking nice a long time.

The laces are cotton and can be handled easily, making for easy on and off. It’s a minor detail, but if you’ve ever had a lace up shoe with bad laces you know why it’s important. You want something you can grip easily and that slides through the grommets without effort.

Belenka shoes are handmade in house, and a lot of care goes into each one. All the stitching looks uniform and every detail is professional. They put a lot of energy into crafting great shoes, and it shows in the final product.

Barefoot Qualities

Belenka is a barefoot brand, so every shoe they make is completely flat, flexible, and thin.

The total stack height of the Icon is 4mm and the new soles are very bendy. I’ve tried a lot of different barefoot brands and am somewhat of a connoisseur (if you will) of sole material, so the following description is very nuanced (otherwise known as obsessive-compulsive).

Some outsoles are squishy and conform to every object they come in contact with. Others are firmer, and while they might be very flexible and rolly don’t take the exact shape of everything they’re pressed against. The new Belenka soles are in the latter category. Typically, the firmer soles are not the best ground feel you can possibly get, but they protect you from the elements and last longer. The soles that let you feel everything tend to wear out faster. Some people also prefer firmness to squish because it improves your proprioception.

There is always a balancing act going on between durability and ground feel. If you’re new to barefoot shoes these subtleties will be nothing compared the newfound freedom and foot stimulation you’re experiencing. But if you’ve really honed your foot preferences (or if you’re a complete nerd like I am), these are details that can inform your purchases.

If I had to compare these outsoles to another brand’s, they are similar in feel to Vivobarefoot’s outsoles.

I think these Belenka soles do a good job of finding the balance, so you get to feel the ground underneath you and won’t wear through your shoes in 6 months.

Sizing

Belenka shoes are unisex with sizes going from 36-46. In the winter boots I was comfortable in a size 37, so I chose the same size in the Icon. I was surprised that it was quite a bit roomier and I needed to use an insole to keep my foot from sliding around. The shoes themselves are the exact same size, but because the winter boots are lined with wool they feel a lot shallower.

Belenka Winter boots size 37 next to Icon Year Round shoes size 37

The winter boots were the first closed toed Belenkas I had tried, so I didn’t realize quite how much space the wool was taking up. I now have a better grasp for how roomy the unlined Belenka shoes are. These 37s still work fine for me and I wouldn’t want to size down, but if I wear them without an insole or felt sticky my foot is not secure and runs into the side when I walk.

I live by my insoles (these and these) and felt stickies because I have low volume feet. They make so many of my shoes fit better.

Injinji socks, Naboso insole, Felt sticky

There is a size chart on each Belenka product page that shows the measurement of the last used to mold the shoe. I wear a size 37 in Vivobarefoot, Zaqq, Feelgrounds and most lace-up shoes and boots. But I wear a size 36 in most dress shoes, and in the brand Luks I wear a size 35.

Comparisons

The following shoe comparisons are all in a size 37

Compared to the above brands, Belenka is roughly the same length but a little wider than all of them. Not significantly wider, but a few millimeter can make a big difference in fit. So if you’ve tried some of the above brands and found them too narrow for you, consider Belenkas.

Unshoes Terra Vidas size 6.5 next to Belenka. The Unshoes fit noticeably shorter than the Belenkas and are more glove-like. Slightly narrower across the toes though.

The only other shoes I have that match Belenka for foot shape are Luks shoes and Softstar Primals. Of those three, the Primals are the widest.

Belenkas and Softstar Primals size 5u (women’s 6)

Sustainability and Ethics

Belenka sources local materials and hand makes all their shoes, so they are involved in every step of the process. In their own words, the Belenka team is “committed to making this world a better place by being a low waste company, having a low carbon footprint and making environmentally safe products.” They choose non-toxic materials and treat all their employees fairly. 95% of the materials used in Belenka shoes and in packaging is recyclable.

Ordering

Belenka Icon shoes are $131 + $16 shipping with DHL (you check out in Euros and it gets converted by your bank/Paypal). They arrive lightning fast with DHL, which is always appreciated. But the most important thing you need to know is that returns are NOT accepted outside the EU. Belenka shoes do resell well, but it is a risk.

Style

I was instantly drawn to the cognac color in the Icon because it reminded me of a classic chukka boot. I love neutral shoes that can be dressed up or down and go with most things, especially in a shoe as wide as Belenkas. Neutral understated tones also understate bulk and keep you looking balanced from head to toe.

If you’ve been following my content you know I’m all about balance. Anything can work, any body shape or size can “pull it off,” it’s just a matter of finding the right balance for you. In shoes like these I balance out the bulk of the shoe with a looser fitting top. Jackets, scarves, or an open button-down shirt all do a great job of it.

If you’re a woman looking to wear these to work, styling them like an oxford with skirts or dress pants would be a good move, but they are a little casual for women’s professional attire. For men, these are a great dress shoe. I especially like these cognac ones for men and of course the shiny black is very work appropriate.

You can also get the Icon in a pretty pink, bright mustard, or flaming red, and if that’s what you love, then by all means GO FOR IT. And then share on Instagram so we can see you rock them!

My only reservation about the updated Icon is how the black walled sole looks with the bright options. On the brown and black it’s great, but on yellow and pink the black sole weighs the shoe down. I would prefer a matching sole or the kind that sits underneath your foot for the bright colors. In the modeling photos Belenka has shared on their Instagram they still look nice when styled, but it’s a deterrent for me.

Conclusion

Belenka is at the top of its barefoot game. For those with extra wide feet there are few options that look this nice. And even if you don’t have trouble fitting in to other barefoot brands, there’s no doubt your feet will feel great in the new Belenka Icon.

9 thoughts on “Belenka Icon Review

  1. Judy Reply

    Hi Anya, just wanted to thank you for your reviews. I belatedly discovered Correcttoes and barefoot shoes, after being told I would need bunion surgery that had a year-long recovery period. In my search for information, I found your blog–it is SO helpful. I have since gone completely barefoot in shoes. Based on your reviews, I’ve bought Vivobarefoot, Magical Shoes, Davinci, Softstars, and I just received my Belenka winter boots today, they are amazing. Your sizing information is invaluable, if you wear a 36, I get a 38. If you get a 37, I get a 39. Everything has fit perfectly–important if your shoes are coming from Bulgaria or Poland. My feet have never been so happy and I’m optimistic I’ll be able to avoid surgery. Keep up the good work!

    • Anya Post authorReply

      This makes me so happy! Good for you for going out on a limb for yourself, I hope you are able to find relief and healing. And also, so glad that my info has helped you get the right size (because it is a huge hassle when you get it wrong). Best of luck to you on your journey!

  2. Heidi Reply

    If my foot measures 24.5cm exactly, does that mean i get a 38 in Belenka or a 39? I dont understand if the insole itself is 24.5 so that my toes would hit the front, or if they are saying it will fit perfectly b/c your foot is 24.5cm and they’ve added a little bit of space to the front to accomodate. (if that makes any sense!) Love your reviews, thanks Anya!

    • Anya Post authorReply

      The measurement on the size chart is the last that is used to form the shoe, so it’s neither the length of the insole or a foot measurement. If the measurement shown is 24.5 you’d probably want to go up a size, since the shoe fits much tighter on a last than you would want it on your foot. But in any case, reaching out to them for sizing advice is always a good idea if you’re on the fence.

  3. Pingback: Mukishoes – Anya's Reviews

  4. Pingback: Men’s Dress Shoes – Anya's Reviews

  5. Linds Reply

    Howdy! Did you pay VAT when you placed an order with Belenka?

    • Anya Post authorReply

      I believe it’s included in the price you see online and there is no deduction if you’re shipping to the US. But I wasn’t able to see any definite info about it on their website.

Leave a Reply to Heidi Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *