An anatomically shaped shoe that allows your toes to spread out is ground zero for foot health. So even though there are good reasons to consider true minimalist shoes, you should give yourself credit for taking what I would consider to be the most important shoe feature seriously! There are quite a few options out there for wide toe box shoes without a barefoot sole.
Are There Barefoot Alternatives to the popular Birkenstock Arizona Sandal?
A Are There Barefoot Alternatives to the popular Birkenstock Arizona Sandal? Softstar Camino Sandals If you want that classic Birkenstock Arizona look without the thick