After my second child was born I developed debilitating (and unexplained) foot, ankle, hip, and low back pain that persisted for a long time – until I started to address the weakness and instability starting with my feet. I’ve made a lot of progress since then, but when you’ve spent decades not understanding your body it takes a while to unravel!
So I was very excited to get an in-person gait analysis with Gait Happens for deeper insight into what I can improve. I’ve been lucky to cross paths with Gait Happens founders Jenifer Perez and Courtney Conley many times over the years and consider them friends – but they’re also amazing at helping people get out of pain! Let’s dive right in to what I learned.
Foot Strength Test
We started out with a foot strength test using a dynamometer. I learned from Dr. Conley that foot and toe strength are hugely important for optimal movement and injury prevention – but how much is enough?
They say you want to be able to generate 10% of your body weight both through your big toe and through the ball of your big toe (which measures outer ankle strength/peroneus longus) and 7% through the outer toes.
So the dynamometer gives you a very real look at whether you have adequate foot strength for your daily life. Here were my results:
Goal | Actual Right | Actual Left | |
Big Toe | 10 lbs | 10 lbs | 7 lbs |
Ball of Big Toe | 10 lbs | 13lbs | 5 lbs |
Outer Toes | 7 lbs | 7 lbs | 7 lbs |
My right foot is on the money in terms of strength. But my left is significantly weaker! And the funny thing is it was my right foot that was injured and painful for so long – to this day it still is prone to issues and has arthritis/joint damage. So it may be that my right side is carrying too much of the burden!
So the strength of my left foot is going to be a focus for me now. I will continue doing this ToePro exercise, but with extra reps on my left side only to help even things out.
Gait Analysis
After the foot strength test we moved to the gait analysis on the treadmill. Oftentimes a static assessment only gives you partial understanding – you may present one way standing still, but then move in an entirely different way. And since a lot of the time our pain comes with movement, it makes sense to look at the body in motion.
Jen took slow motion video of me walking on the treadmill from all angles and was able to show me immediately a few things she noticed. The biggest red flag here was that I lift my toes a lot, especially on my (weaker) left foot.
This is called extensor substitution because the extensor muscles that lift the toes are doing what the tibialis anterior muscle (that flexes the ankles) should be doing. Extensor substitution can suggest limited ankle range of motion, but that’s not the case for this hypermobile girl.
Dr. Perez confirmed with a strength test that I actually just don’t have a lot of strength in my tibialis anterior, which runs up the front and side of your lower leg. In layman’s terms: I don’t have the strength to lift my foot high enough to clear the ground without extra help from my toes lifting (toe extensor substitution).
To work on this musculature imbalance I’ve added in these weighted tibial lifts. I’m also trying it with an elastic band under the direction of my physical therapist (good if you don’t have a kettlebell). This should help even things out so that nothing is being under or overused.
Another finding from the slow motion video was that I have medial heel whip – my heel whips in to the midline of my body when I lift it off the ground instead of staying straight. This finding (and the solution) was confirmed in the next step: a pedograph.
Pedograph
The 3rd component to my gait analysis was a pedograph. I walked over a special stamp that left a foot print on paper – the shading shows the pressure distribution through my feet as I walk.
My pedograph shows less shading under the big toe portion of the ball of my foot. Because in the dynamometer strength test I had good strength on my right side and significantly less strength of the left side, this relatively even pressure on the right and left suggests that I have a patterning issue. Meaning that regardless of the strength I have, my peroneus longus (that muscle on the outer ankle which helps the ball of the foot stay down) isn’t as involved as it should be in the gait cycle. This makes a lot of sense, as I get intermittent outer ankle pain – right where peroneus longus runs.
I am already going to be working on improving left foot and ankle strength, but for this in-motion issue I need to practice using peroneus longus more in-motion. To specifically help with that, I’ll be adding in this Peroneus Longus Patterning exercise.
I think this one will give me lot of bang for my buck because of how important the big toe is for good gait – and since I hope to take many thousands of steps every day for many more years to come, I’d like to have good gait.
Hip Assessment
The final piece was assessing my hips/pelvis, because this can affect and be affected by everything down the chain. Jen found a strength discrepancy between my left and right hip (unsurprising at this point), and that my right hip is rotated forward. I’ve known about my hip issues for a while, but only recently have begun to actively work on balancing the strength between both sides. I’ll be adding this exercise back in to work on improving symmetry and alignment.
What I Learned
My key takeaways are that I have a few areas of weakness that should make life easier by addressing. I totally did not have tibialis anterior/shin strength on my radar, so it was very helpful to have that weak link made known to me.
And the patterning issue of not getting enough pressure under the ball of my foot during the gait cycle also made a lot of sense given what has been hurting. I walked away with a few very actionable insights and I am excited to see where it takes me. Thank you Gait Happens!
Gait Happens provides virtual consultations as well as in-person consultations via their local practices – Total Health Solutions and Kinetic Chiropractic, both in Colorado.
9 thoughts on “Findings From a Gait Analysis – How to Move Without Pain”
Where can one get a gait analysis done? I feel like I need to get this done and then have a therapist help me make corrections.
Thanks for sharing!!
Jen and Courtney are in Colorado, and they do in-person consultations like this one via their local practices Total Health Solutions and Kinetic Chiropractic. They also do virtual consultations via their Gait Happens company where you send them video from all angles and they can tell a lot from it. I don’t know of any other places to go.
Hi Anya, do you think exercises and stretches could help with alleviating pain from standing? I’m currently trying to figure out a solution for my foot pain which is probably stemming from standing for 8+ hours per day on a hard tile floor at work. Unfortunately, there really isn’t a way around that aspect since it’s part of the nature of the job, and I’ve already been wearing barefoot shoes for years, so I’m running out of ideas. Is there any way to make the standing more tolerable and fix this pain? Thanks!
Oof, that is rough! I would start with adding some cushion or an insole to your shoes (a few ideas here) – because standing that long on hard floor is a lot to ask of anyone’s feet. And do you have any way of breaking up the standing? Can you put anything at the desk to stand on that is softer/different texture? Even a stool next to you that you could put a foot up on would help keep you changing positions. I would also imagine that exercises and stretches when you are not at work would help, but that is more Gait Happens terrain.
Thanks Anya, I got the NorthSole extra cushion and they seem to help a little. Sadly there’s no way to improve the comfort of the environment at all because of the nature of the job itself; it’s not that they don’t want to accommodate, it’s just not possible. I think massaging outside of work is helping with muscle pain although skeletal pain persists.
Hi,
An experienced pilates instructor could help a lot by using apparatuses such as the Pilates Foot Corrector, and the Pilates Toe Stretcer / Toe Gizmo
Thank you for sharing! I also have noticed my toes lifting when I walk and curling when trying to ground down, but on my right. I have also recently realized my right hip and glutes are weaker, all of which I think is contributing to my left hip pain. Bodies are amazing! I will add in some of these exercises and hope to see a change. Thank you!
PS. Is there a place to submit requests? For shoe suggestions for a type of foot/issue or for you to use your clout for a specific type of shoe to be made. 😉
You can email us! info@anyasreviews.com
Thank you for sharing. This is very helpful since I experience similar issues (hypermobility, toes up while walking and pain in the right part of the body after pregnancy). One thing I recently have noticed is that I always pick up things from the floor with my right hip/leg and as a mom I do that A LOT, which might be one of the reasons my right side is overworked and my left is undertrained, mom picking up syndrom 😉