Slippers Your Feet Will Love

With holiday season and cold weather fast approaching I am ready to cozy up with warm tootsies. You would think it goes without saying that a house slipper would have plenty of toe space, but so many of the ones I’ve tried over the years have been tight in the toes while sliding off my heel! If you’ve struggled to find actually comfortable slippers, you’re in the right place.

Here are my tried-and-true ACTUALLY wide foot-shaped slippers that won’t pinch your feet so you can be cozy and comfy all season long.

The Best Barefoot Slippers

I work from home doing all the barefoot shoe things, so slippers are kind of a must-have for me. Especially because I live in the Midwest where it’s cold half the year! The following are the all time favorites for myself, Justin (my husband and co-founder) and Samantha (my lovely wide-footed assistant). Oh, and if you’re looking for cozy socks to pair with them that also won’t squish your toes, check out this list of my recommended foot-friendly socks.

Alright, it’s slipper time!

Zeazoo Sheepskin

Sheepskin | Vibram rubber Outsole | Sizes EU 34-45

You can also order direct from Zeazoo in the EU and get 5% off with code ANYASREVIEWS.

Zeazoo sheepskin slippers are so fluffy!! They are also incredibly warm for how light and soft they are. Truly like clouds for your feet. You can find a few different cuts and variations from Zeazoo, depending on your fit and style preferences. The Dolly (above right) is quite high volume, so my heel slips if I wear them barefoot. For that reason the Dingo (left) is a better slipper option for me. When I’m working at home on a cold winter day, these are lifesavers.

Zeazoo slippers are considerably warmer than Mukishoes slippers and probably not best for people who run hot.

Sizing & Fit:

• Runs on the roomy side, but true to size for length.
• Wide width – the Dingo feels slightly narrower in the toe box than Dolly and Shaun
• High volume, especially in Dolly and Shaun. Choose Dingo or Dingo Mini if medium to low volume.

I have a size 36/37 and they feel looser than other slippers in the same size, but I don’t think I could size down.

Mukishoes Soca

Felted Wool or Cotton | Natural Rubber Outsole | Sizes EU 36-48*

*Sizes EU 44-48 of the Soca Lana only available directly from Mukishoes in the EU. Use code ANYAMUKI for 10% off there.

Mukishoes has two slipper models, both made of natural materials. The Soca Nuvem is a cotton plush slipper that is so soft and cozy – I joke that they look like giant pom poms on my feet. They are plush throughout the entire inside and the insole. And the other is Soca Lana, made of felted wool. These are not as plush feeling, but they are quite warm and also dang cute.

These are great slippers for a chilly but not frigid environment because the heel is open. For me, that’s in the fall and spring. Oh, and the Soca Nuvem is in fact vegan (cotton upper, rubber sole, microfiber straps)

Sizing & Fit:

• Runs true to size – I have a size 37 in both.
• Medium to wide width – these are unstructured and flexible, so the material spreads out and molds to my foot shape. But I wouldn’t recommend for extra wide.
• Lana medium to high volume, Nuvem works well for low to high volume because the plush can compress or fill in space depending on the foot shape. Both also have a top strap for some adjustability.

Kingdom of Wow – Extra Wide Friendly

Wool & Plant-based Yarn | Sizes 3XS-3XL (EU 35-48)

Use code ANYASREVIEWS for 5% off

These are so dang comfy, I wear my Kingdom of Wow slippers in both high and low cut all the time. The lightweight version (75% New Zealand wool and 25% botanical fibers) is not as warm as the others and can be worn a lot of the year. The cozier slippers (65% New Zealand wool and 35% botanical fibers) are thicker and warmer, but still light (similar in warmth to Mukishoes). They have taken the shape of my feet and are just so easy to wear!

I tend to reach for the slip-ons most often because they are the easiest to put on and work great almost year round. One pair of my KOW slippers is two years old and even after all that use they are still in great condition. They’ve stretched some, but not excessively, and you can put them in the washing machine when dirty.

Sizing & Fit:

• Slightly small when new – I have a Women’s 7.5-8 (a size bigger than I would normally take) in all mine, and they are a good fit with a pair of socks.
• Wide width – the shape conforms to your foot, so they are adaptable for a lot of different shapes. Extra wide feet may spill over the sides, which can cause the material to wear through faster there.
• All volumes – they work on my low volume feet, and will stretch to fit higher volume feet (but might be snug at first)

Softstar Fireside & Smore – Extra Wide Friendly

Suede & Sheepskin | Sizes 5U-13U | 2 Width Options | Handmade in the USA

I have been wearing this same pair of slippers the last 6 or 7 years – they are incredibly comfortable and high quality and very roomy. Over the years they stretched out and became a little floppy because the fur on the insole flattened out (leaving me with extra room). But last year I replaced the insoles and it made them feel brand new again.

They come in two widths, and the wide is extra wide friendly. Mine are a size 5u (women’s 6) wide, which is on the smaller end of what I would normally choose for a slipper. But they are still plenty roomy and I definitely wouldn’t size up. Softstar also makes a rubber bottom version called S’More!

And you can find a Merino Zen slipper in their collection too, which is a felted wool. They are a nice house shoe! My son likes them.

Sizing & Fit:

• Should fit snug when new – I recommend getting a size down
• Fits average, wide and extra wide feet!
• Medium to high volume fit

Wildling Slinka Sten

Undyed Felted Wool | Rubber Sole | Sizes EU 23-48

Use code ANYA for €5/$10 off your purchase.

These felted wool slippers are the only ones on this list that are step-in friendly (hands free!) and come in the entire size range from little kids to large men’s sizes. The wool is thick and warm (thicker than Mukishoes Soca Lana and Softstar Merino Zen), and the outsoles are just grippy enough to not be slippery but still quiet on my floors.

They are on the higher volume side and I like to pair them with one of their wool insoles (does not come included) for a better fit. Even still, they’re a little floppy on my low volume feet and I prefer to wear them while reclining but not walking around. They will work best for people who want that hands-free feature and have higher volume feet.

Sizing & Fit:

• Runs big. I tried a 38 first and they were way too big. Now I have a 37 and I still have lots of room and can wear socks with them.
• Wide fit
• Medium to high volume

Xero Pagosa Cozy

Synthetic Fleece | Rubber Outsole | Sizes US Women’s 5 – Men’s 15

These fleece slippers are so cozy, they’re like a warm fleece jacket for your feet. They also have a rubber bottom and a collapsible heel for quick slide in if you don’t want to put them fully on. They fit both Justin and me really securely, and are so soft. If you are looking for a cheaper or an animal free alternative to the sheepskin and wool options here that is still warm and structured, this is the best one. Overall pretty big fan! Especially because so many options are high volume, and I have a narrow ankle and heel.

You can get the regular Pagosa too if you want a house shoe that isn’t so warm. Justin has been wearing his religiously for the past few years.

Sizing & Fit:

• Slightly small – I have a US 7 and find them just big enough for me, but Justin’s usual size was too small for him.
• Medium wide, not suited for extra wide toe splay
• Medium volume

Verloop – Extra Wide Friendly

Vegan | Fleece Lined | Sizes XS – M/L | Ships from USA

Samantha has these knit slippers and loves them! They have a bit more cushion to the sole when brand new, but it compresses with just a couple wears (and some people might like that extra squish!). They are also a good price point for a cozy wide toe box slipper.

The knit uppers are stretchy and the soles are super flexible with plenty of grip for indoor use. They’re also sustainably made with deadstock yarn and they’re machine washable! We recommend the Verloop slippers with backs for a secure fit. Oh, and the fun prints and colors are a win.

Sizing & Fit:

• True to size
• Extra wide friendly
• Medium to high volume (the high top booties are higher volume than the low cut slippers)

More Foot-Friendly Slippers

The above are my favorites, but here are a few more good foot-friendly slipper options.