Softstar Shoes Review – The Primal Merry Jane

*Disclosure – Anya’s Reviews is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no additional cost to you.

Softstar Shoes is one of my favorite small businesses. They hand make all shoes in their Oregon workshop, blending together excellent craftsmanship along with the features of functional footwear. At Softstar you can find classic shoe styles that will appeal to a mainstream audience, as well as some of the absolute widest and most foot-friendly shoes out there.

This fall they are playing to their serious foot fans with a new addition to their primal line – The Primal Merry Jane. Read on for my full review!

Meet The Primal Merry Jane

The Primal Merry Jane is a classic flat style made to fit the widest of toes so there’s no compromising on foot function. It has the same sole shape as the other models in the Primal line, but designed to be a women’s dress shoe.

Materials

A soft, supple leather is used on the upper and interior of the shoe (double lined, so you’re not getting raw leather on your skin). The outsole is flexible Vibram, and the whole shoe is soft and roll-y. A unique strapping detail adds interest to the shoe, and internal stitching allows for plenty of width but a smooth edge. The insole is leather and sits on top of a cushioned pad (the same one used in the popular Softstar Ballerine).

IMG_0963
IMG-0968
IMG-0970
IMG-0969
previous arrow
next arrow

I chose the deep Elderberry color, but you currently can choose from 3 different colors: Elderberry (purple), Blaze (bright red) and Aged Acorn (brown). Softstar is known for having beautiful bright leather colors that are soft and don’t rub off with wear, unlike other cheap plasticky leather. There was no breaking in required and the shoes were immediately comfortable from the start.

Barefoot Qualities

All Softstar shoes are zero drop (completely flat) and flexible. In addition to that, the PMJ boasts a toe box shape that not only follows the natural shape of the human foot, but also gives extra space for toes to splay when you move. That means you can stretch, exercises your toes and even wear toe spacers with these shoes on!

The total stack height of the PMJ is between 5-6mm, so there is a little bit of cushion but you still can feel rocks and bumps underneath.

Sizing

I have 4 different styles from Softstar and typically wear a size 5U (women’s 6). They have a handy size chart and videos to help you determine your size, and I highly recommend making use of it before purchasing. I have a 5u in both the Primal Sawyer and the Primal Merry Jane and they both fit well with plenty of space for full toe splay, including Correct Toes.

The Primal Merry Jane comes in a regular (previously called narrow) and wide width (previously called regular). The shoes you see on me are regular. Yes that’s right, the wide width is even wider in the toe box than the ones you see here. Barefoot shoe blogger Mel reviewed these shoes in the wider width, you can check out her Primal Mary Jane review to see the difference. Below is an image illustrating the different soles (old names – green is now regular, blue is wide).

a graphic showing a size comparison between the regular and narrow width of the primal softstar shoes sole
Image Source: Softstar Shoes

My right foot measures 23.1 cm long and 9.3 cm wide from a foot tracing. I am able to fit into most barefoot brands, but in general am narrow in the heels and wide in the forefoot. In some of the narrower barefoot brands (like Vivobarefoot and Mukishoes) I must wear them without socks in order to have enough space around my toes. I still do perfectly fine in the narrow width in the Primals.

Comparisons

Softstar has a wide variety of styles, and some of them fit very differently from each other. Let’s take a look at some other Softstar shoes next to the Primal MJ. First up the, the Primal Sawyer.

The Primal Sawyer is a unisex shoe that follows the same shape as the PMJ. In this shoe I have a 5u regular width, and have loads of extra space in the toe box. I am able to wear a regular width comfortably in both, even though you can see that the Sawyer is constructed differently. So if you’ve tried the Sawyer before, the sizing is consistent between these two styles and you’ll likely wear the same size and width.

The Ballerine is another women’s dress shoe from Softstar that has internal stitching. I love internal stitching (as opposed to a top stitch) in a women’s dress shoe because it minimizes the bulk of the shoe and makes for a cleaner look. The Ballerine, while still a barefoot shoe, has a much narrow toe box than the PMJ. Shown here is the Ballerine in 5u Regular width pewter color.

The Ballerine also comes in a wide width, however it is the same shape as the regular only wider. You can see that the shoes from the Primal line follows a different shape around the toe box entirely. I fit comfortably in the Ballerine regular, but the material is close around my toes and I don’t have much space for toe splay.

softstar shoes ballerines pewter close up
You can see my toes fill up the entire space of the shoes.

Style

Ultra wide shoes that are dressy and feminine are pretty hard to come by. While it’s certainly not the norm to see foot-shaped shoes on a woman in dressy situations, I’m a firm believer that confidence is the the most attractive thing you can wear. Wear these PMJs with your normal outfits just like any flat, but unlike any flat your feet will be able to move just like they would when barefoot.

Conclusion

If you’re a Primal fan, this new Merry Jane is for you! Softstar has delivered the widest and most foot shaped women’s dress shoe I’ve seen, and it also happens to be well made with high quality materials. Who’s excited?

If you like barefoot shoes, make sure you subscribe below for e-mail updates!

Share This Post:

Tagged:

Subscribe to the Barefoot Shoe Digest™

Stay up to date on all the best shoes, current sales, newest releases, and more

You May Also Like:

Comments

21 thoughts on “Softstar Shoes Review – The Primal Merry Jane”

  1. Hi Anya, I always love your style! many times i’ve wondered where you get this or where you get that. Anyway, just wondering if you have tried the wide soft star ballerines? i’m looking for some shoes I can wear to work, I currently don’t have any barefoot shoes, I used to have a pair of Vivo Jazz shoes, they were amazing, but I washed them (they were canvas) too hot and they shrunk 🙁 anyway finding it hard to find something I actually like and can justify paying so much for, I ordered a few pairs of Groundies but I just can’t seem to get used to a foot shaped shoe so sent them back!

    1. Hi! Thank you! You can always ask 🙂 I haven’t tried the Softstar Ballerine in wide, they are shaped the same way but wider through the whole shoe. Since I have narrow heels I think they wouldn’t be secure. But they have a nice conventional look to them still!

  2. Thanks so much for this review; I can’t wait to get a pair! The image of the narrow vs the regular width doesn’t seem to be displaying, though.

    1. I tested it on multiple devices and it seems to be showing everywhere I check! I can send the image to you in a DM on Instagram if you’re still unable to see it. Thanks for letting me know.

      1. Hi Anya, my foot length is 23cm and width 10cm. Would you recommend the 5U in the wider fit for the Merry Janes. Thankyou.

  3. Malka Greenberg

    Hi Anya, Thank you for all your very helpful information!
    I want to buy the Balerine flats. I tried your code ANYA and it said not valid. Any suggestions?

    1. It’s probably because you need to be signed into an account to use it. Otherwise it’ll come back as being invalid. Hope that solves the issue!

      1. I also tried to use the ANYA code, but it came back invalid. I did create an account and ensured I was signed in. Thank you, Anya, for all of your resources!

        1. Hi Meg, unfortunately the codes were just deactivated this week. Softstar has decided not to use them anymore. Previously people had trouble because you had to have an account, but now they really aren’t working. I’ll make sure they get take off the website!

  4. Hi Anya. What is the colour of the Sawyers you’re showing here? I just received a pair that were described as ‘loden’ on the site. They looked kind of a sandy colour there, but in reality look like these greenish ones you’re showing here.

  5. These look great and I love that they come in larger sizes. What volume would you say they have? Did you need any extra insole or cushioning with your low volume feet?

  6. Is there a similar style that would work well for a narrow, low volume, mountain foot? I like the simplicity of the design and the security of the strap, but I know my feet would be swimming in the PMJs.

  7. Hello,

    I just tried to use the ANYA code, and they said that this code has been discontinued and to please let you know so that you can update your web page.

    Thanks!

  8. I’ve had a pair of the PMJs now for several months and they are my absolute favorite pair of barefoot shoes. It feels like I’m completely barefoot when I wear them. And they’re great for wearing correctoes with🙌

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Picture of Hi. I'm Anya.

Hi. I'm Anya.

I first discovered barefoot shoes after a long history of foot issues. By changing my footwear and strengthening my body I was able to completely transform my life. Anya’s Reviews is my way of sharing with the world that healthy feet are happy feet!

Follow Me

Subscribe for weekly updates

Check out our shop!

Shoe Finder

Popular Posts

Archives
Scroll to Top

Thank you for subscribing!

So I can serve you better, can you answer this one quick question?

What is the #1 thing I can help you with?

Subscribe to the Barefoot Shoe Digest™

Stay up to date on all the best shoes, current sales, newest releases, and more.