The All Time Warmest Barefoot Winter Boots for Snow

*Disclosure – Anya’s Reviews is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no additional cost to you.

A top down view of a family's feet standing in the snow wearing wide toe box barefoot winter boots with the text "When your toes need space, but it's winter"
You don’t need to compromise.

I can’t do squished toes anymore. But I also spend time outside everyday, no matter the weather. So for the last decade I’ve made it my mission to find and test the most practical, but also truly comfortable, naturally fitting barefoot and wide toe box snow boots.

I present to you the best of the best barefoot winter boots that have a wide toe box and natural feel. No foot pain this winter please! But also, let’s stay warm and secure on ice and snow.

Staying Warm in Barefoot Winter Boots

A comparison of two shearling winter boots side by side in a top down view to show the toe box shape and width. On the left is the Vivobarefoot Tracker Pioneer Shearling with a foot-shaped toe box and on the right is a similar style boot in a narrow pointy shape with the text "Wear This, Not That" superimposed over the image.

Foot-shaped winter boots just make sense. There is no need for cramped toes or a stiff, rigid heel when you’re trying to navigate cold weather conditions. In fact, I would argue that you have more stability in a zero drop, flexible, and wide boot!

But before we get to the actual shoes, here are a few of my best tips for getting the most versatility out of your comfy, wide, snow boots this winter.

And finally, in this post I talk about what type of feet these boots are best for to help you avoid costly mistakes. Find Your Foot Type Here.

Alright, let’s dig in to the best barefoot winter boots. First we’ll cover the best warm boots for snow and traction, and then the best for everyday comfort and warmth.

Best for Snow

1. Vivobarefoot

Use code ANYASREVIEWS25 for 25% off

If you are in the UK, shop this link. If you are in the EU or the rest of the world, shop Vivobarefoot here.

Vivobarefoot has quite the winter line up this year, with something for every kind of weather.

Canvas & Wool | Rated to -50F / -46C | Traction: Snow – Great, Ice – Great

The showstopper for the most serious of winter weather is the Tundra ESC (find the men’s version here). It’s suitable even for arctic conditions, with a felted wool boot liner and insoles – the first of its kind in the natural footwear world and a real achievement! These fit pretty wide already, which is not typical for Vivobarefoot. And the wool bootie tamps down with wear to become even roomier.

Vivobarefoot Tracker Pioneer Warm winter barefoot boot

Sheepskin & Leather or Vegan| Rated to -25F / 32C | Traction: Snow – Great, Ice – Great

If you don’t need quite the level of functionality of the Tundra, the Tracker Pioneer (find the men’s version here) is at a lower price point and not such an ordeal to put on, while still being a great snow boot.

They also have the Tracker Pioneer Shearling which is made of real shearling. Not waterproof though! For serious warmth I recommend replacing the insole with felted wool.

A pair of feet standing on concrete wearing barefoot snow boots from Vivobarefoot - the Tracker Winter

Leather | Rated to 15F / -10C | Traction: Snow – Great, Ice – Good

The Tracker Winter is a waterproof, insulated version of their hiking boot that I quite like as a snow shoe. They are kind of stiff when new, and I like to size up in them for space. But really functional for shoveling the walk or hiking in snow. Men’s version here. Again, I prefer a wool insole.

Sizing & Fit

  • Wide width (Tundra) & Medium width (Tracker)
  • Sloped, so not the best fit for square shaped feet. The Tundra has the roomiest toe box.
  • Medium volume. But the Tundra and Pioneer are highly adjustable for different foot volumes.
  • Runs slightly long – I normally size up in winter boots but didn’t need to in any of these except for the Tracker Winter. Those I got in a 38, the rest are size 37.

2. Lems Shoes

Close up side view of a pair of Lems Breck insulated wide toe box winter boots being worn by a man in deep snow.

Lems is an in-between brand with a more traditional thicker outsole, but a wide toe box and natural fit. Great for people who want to take care of their feet but aren’t ready for full barefoot! Or if you just need something super practical for the winter, Lems has you covered. However if you want that flexibility and ground feel, I’d choose something else on this list.

And if you’re overseas, shop Lems EU here.

Side close up of a pair of Lems Insulated Brek winter barefoot boots with a wide toe box being worn outside on very snowy ground

Leather | Rated to 0F / -18C | Traction: Snow – Great, Ice – Good

The Breck boot is a taller cut, waterproof boot with a side zip and the same thicker outsole. This year they come in an insulated version, and I find them to be a stellar snow boot and all-purpose cold weather boot. The sole is definitely robust and not super flexible. They also are not fully zero drop, but have a 3mm heel rise. For me this is an acceptable compromise in a winter boot that goes on fast, but if you are sensitive you may notice it.

Top down view of a pair of legs in Lems Shoes Chelsea Tuff wide toe box boots with a warm collar lining

Leather | Rated to 5F / -15C | Traction: Snow – Great, Ice – Good

The Chelsea Tuff Waterproof has an insulated lining that is surprisingly warm. The sole is quite thick (makes me feel so tall!) but flexes at the toe. Really well-made shoes with a grippy practical outsole. I use them a lot when I’m heading out the door fast. Make sure you choose the waterproof version, as it is warmer.

a close up side view of a pair of feet standing in a puddle in the rain wearing Dakota brown Lems barefoot waterproof Boulder boot grip with a non slip sole

Leather | Rated to 5F / -15C | Traction: Snow – Great, Ice – Good

The Boulder Boot Summit is the warmest Boulder boot option from Lems, with the same outsole as on the Breck boot. So it’s got good grip and is well insulated. I personally prefer the Boulder Boot Grip, because it’s lighter and more flexible (and also fully zero drop). But if you want the extra warmth the Summit is a good one!

Sizing & Fit

  • Wide – not quite as wide as the Lems Primal Zen or Chelsea suede, but still quite generous.
  • Plateau shaped – may not work for really square feet, but should for most others.
  • Medium to high volume.
  • Runs small. I consistently size up a half size larger than I do in most barefoot boot brands. Mine are all a women’s 8.

3. Xero Alpine

Two people standing toe to toe on grass with fallen leaves. They are both wearing Xero Alpine warm winter pull on barefoot boots with a wide toe box. The person on the left is wearing a white pair, while the person on the right is wearing an olive green pair.

Waterproof | Vegan | Rated to -15F / -26C | Ships from USA

Traction Rating: Snow – Great | Ice – Ok

Outside the US? Shop Xero EU here!

A pair of white Xero Alpine pull on puffer winter boots being worn by a person against a very snowy ground.

The Alpine Pull-On is new for 2025 and my favorite Xero winter boot. They are surprisingly warm for how lightweight they are, and so easy to pull on and off. You get some adjustability with the toggle, but they are quite roomy through the heel so I don’t recommend sizing up. They’re loose on my narrow heels, so I need to wear thick socks with them. They’ll fit higher volume feet best, but I like having a really warm easy pull on option.

A woman wearing a pair of Xero Alpine barefoot boots in deep snow.

The Xero Alpine is not as warm or as flexible as the Alpine Pull-on, but it does cinch around your foot much better so is more secure. I think they’d be good for a slightly warmer climate than mine (I’m thinking Rocky Mountains), but not my top pick for frigid midwest winters. I did swap out the insole for a sheepskin one and that helped a lot (it always does!). The sole is on the stiff side, and I found them to be slippery on ice (but fine in snow).

Sizing & Fit

  • Medium to wide width. The Alpine Pull-On is better suited to wide and extra wide feet than the lace up.
  • Mountain shape (rounded toe box)
  • High volume
  • The Alpine boot runs on the small side, but the Alpine Pull-On runs bigger! I wear an 8 in Alpine and a 7.5 in the Pull-On.

4. Be Lenka Winter Boots – Extra Wide Friendly

Code ANYASREVIEWS gives you 5% off when you shop in the EU store.

Be Lenka Barefoot has 3 excellent options to choose from, and all have a generous wide toe box for real comfort. The soles on these are about the same thickness as Xero and Vivo’s winter boots – so that is to say that they are still pretty thin and flexible while having some robustness to them.

Top down view of a pair of Be Lenka Snowfox warm wide toe box winter boots in a cranberry color with cinchable laces.

Textile | Rated to -15F/-26C | Traction: Snow – Great, Ice – Great

The Be Lenka Snowfox is a pull on boot with adjustable ties, making them easy to put on and off AND secure on foot. They have a soft fluffy lining that is pretty warm and also waterproof.

You can also find the Snowfox directly from Be Lenka in the EU

A front and side close up of a pair of Be Lenka Winter 3.0 barefoot wide toe box boots being worn in deep snow

Leather & Wool | Rated to -10F/-23C | Traction: Snow – Great, Ice – Good

The Winter 3.0 is also wool lined, highly water resistant, and on the same functional outsole, but has more of a traditional dressy look. They’re a good hybrid everyday & snow boot, and have a real wool lining (the others from Be Lenka is synthetic).

If outside the US, shop here.

A close up of a person in wide snow pants and Be Lenka barefoot Arctic Edge snow boots with a wide toe box and flat outsole

Textile | Rated to 0F/-18C | Traction: Snow – Great, Ice – Great

The ArcticEdge is warm, water resistant, and has great traction. They are not high cut, so are kind of like an insulated sneaker. I like the lace up style for when I need to use my feet – I feel more nimble in these than in big snow boots.

Besides these, Be Lenka has a variety of fleece-lined boots that are cozy and nice but not as winter-friendly.

Sizing & Fit Type

  • Extra wide – but the insulation in the Snowfox and Winter can make them feel a little snugger.
  • Square shaped
  • Versatile volume
  • Runs small and I size up to a 38 consistently.

Saguaro Rise

Textile, Suede, & Faux Fur | Waterproof | Rated to 5F / -15C | Ships from Asia

Traction Rating: Snow – Great | Ice – OK

Use code ANYASREVIEWS for 15% off

Saguaro makes the cheapest practical barefoot snow boots to date! They have a variety of options that can be a bit hard to keep track of (they go in and out of stock often) but you can reliably find waterproof, insulated, and roomy boots with functional outsoles.

My experience with Saguaro boots is that they run small and I size up consistently. And shipping can be a bit slow from Saguaro. But if you are in need of an affordable waterproof snow boot this is the best there is!

Sizing & Fit Type

  • Wide to extra wide fit in most models. The Rise is more medium width.
  • Mountain shaped toe box
  • Runs small – size up one.

Freet Arken 2 – Extra Wide Friendly

Use code ANYA10 for 10% off! If you live in the UK, shop Freet here. For EU residents, shop here.

The Freet Arken is an insulated waterproof boot with quite a cozy upper. Like in Vivobarefoot boots, I find the insole to be not warm enough for winter so I recommend replacing it for a wool alternative. Once swapped out these are very warm.

The outsole has lugs that works best for soft ground – snow, mud, grass. I recommend these for cold weather hiking where you don’t get deep snow (because they are a shorter height).

Sizing & Fit Type

  • Wide to extra wide fit – will work for many extra wide feet too if you size up.
  • Plateau shaped toe box
  • Medium to low volume, but laces can open up for more space.
  • Runs small.

I sized up to a 38 and they’re still a little snug, but I can wear medium weight wool socks with them.


Steger Mukluks – Extra Wide Friendly

Leather | Wool Lined | Rated to -50F / -46C | Ships from USA

Traction Rating: Snow – Great | Ice – Great

Steger Mukluks are supremely warm and also wide and flexible. The insole and body of the boots are lined with 9mm thick felted wool that is moisture wicking and built for extreme temps. The outsole is rubber and surprisingly grippy on ice and show. The exterior is high quality moose hide (both soft and super durable).

The outsole on is made of grippy rubber and has a 5mm heel rise, so these are not zero drop. To me, 3mm and below is acceptable in a snow boot but 5mm is pushing it a little. However, for some people in really cold climates, this small heel lift may be worth it, because of how warm they are (and because they are not as expensive as Vivobarefoot’s Tundra Esc boots).

None of the Steger models come waterproof, so I also bought their waterproof spray and treated my boots before wearing them. It has worked great for me, whenever my boots get wet the water beads up and rolls off the leather instead of soaking in. I reapply it each fall and they look almost brand new even after several winters! And I hear repeatedly from readers who have owned Stegers for 5, 10, even 20 years and they are still going strong.

To be as close to a barefoot winter boot (and as warm) as possible, use them with the felted wool insole instead of the supportive insole (boots ship with both). And if you have low volume feet like me you might even want to order an extra felt insole and layer both inside the shoe.

Sizing & Fit Type

  • 3 widths fit average to extra wide feet
  • Square toe box fits most foot shapes
  • High volume
  • True to size

Note that the felted lining tamps down with use! So they might feel pretty snug at first, but you will get more room as you wear them. I ordered a Women’s 7 Wide for my wide feet and they are very spacious after a few years. You can also call in to Steger’s shop and ask for internal measurements.

If you have low volume, narrow heels, and/or thin ankles, expect to need an extra insole, thick socks, or leg warmers to make these a secure fit. You also might want to order a model with ties so you can tighten them on your leg. If you have thicker ankles and calves and don’t need the ties, Steger also has models that are just pull-on.


Best for Everyday Warmth

The following warm barefoot winter boots are cozy and comfortable, but not as functional for lots of time outdoors in wintry conditions. They are your lifestyle boots, but made warmer than most other barefoot boots!

Shapen Cozy – Extra Wide Friendly

Leather | Wool Lining | Rated to 5F/-15C | Ships from EU or US

Traction Rating: Snow – Ok | Ice – Ok

Use code ANYAS10 for 10% off full-priced items, or code ANYA5 for an extra 5% off sale items directly from Shapen in the EU. We also have this model at Anya’s Shop in the US.

The Shapen Cozy is so light and soft, they are perfect for someone who has sensitive feet that get irritated by stiff heel cups. I have reached for mine almost daily the last four winters since they were released and thoroughly enjoy them every time. They are an excellent cozy barefoot boot with the right balance of softness, toe space, and grip.

The Cozy is my favorite comfy warm boot option from Shapen, but they also carry the Urbaneer (similar but without a side zip) and the Frosty (fine, but not my favorite). This is a good brand for people with extra wide feet that have a hard time fitting into other brands.

Sizing & Fit

  • Extra wide fit
  • Square shaped toe box
  • Medium to high volume
  • Runs slightly big

Unlike many lined boots, the Shapen Cozy does not run small. I am still wearing a size 38, but I have more room than I do in most of my other size 38 barefoot boots (they fit almost like a 39). I still don’t recommend sizing down in most cases because you’ll likely want to be able to wear socks.


Peerko Frost

Leather | Wool Lining | Rated to 5F/-15C | Ships from EU or US

Traction Rating: Snow – Ok | Ice – Ok

Code ANYASREVIEWS10 gives you 10% off your order. Peerko doesn’t accept returns outside the EU, but we carry the Frost in the US at Anya’s Shop.

The Peerko Frost is probably the most stylish barefoot winter boot in the bunch! The smooth leather is naturally water resistant, and you can waterproof them yourself for extra protection. The outsole isn’t the best for winter terrain (it’s thin so doesn’t keep the cold out as long as others), so I prefer to use them for warmth as I go around town as opposed to playing in the snow or hiking. But if you’re someone who needs to look nice in the winter AND spend time walking around outside they are excellent.

Sizing & Fit Type

  • Wide toe box
  • Medium volume
  • Runs slightly small because of wool lining, but I wear my usual size.

Peerko boots have a pretty universal fit and are well loved across the board. They probably won’t suite someone with an extra wide toe splay, and you may want to size up one because of the thick lining. I wear mine in a 38.


El Naturalista Nomada Lace-Up Winter

Leather | Lambswool lined | Rated to 0F / -18C | Ships from US

Traction Rating: Snow – Good | Ice – Good

The El Naturalista Nomada Winter is new this year and is fully lined with a thick soft wool. That combined with a thicker sole than you typically find on barefoot boots makes for an all around warm and plush experience. They still feel roomy on the toes even with the thick lining, and they lace securely around different foot volumes so that you don’t slide inside. I also think they are one of the best looking options available that are this warm. A similar classiness to the Peerko Frost, but with an overall bulkier and warmer feel.

Sizing & Fit Type

  • Wide toe box
  • Medium volume
  • True to size, but fits closer because of wool lining

Xanthe Anna (UK)

A pair of handmade sheepskin boots from the UK shown in brown, tan, and leopard

Sheepskin & Veg Tanned Leather | | Rated to -25F / -32C | Sizes EU 35-47 | Ships from UK

These sheepskin boots from Xanthe Anna are very high quality and really really warm. They also have a wide, generous toe box. The sole is quite thick and not super flexible, but that may be what you need in the winter. In fact, at first I was a little put off by it but then came to appreciate the warmth it gave me. One thing I love about sheepskin is it can be worn with or without socks because of the breathable, moisture wicking properties. I reach for these on the coldest days of the year for my walks.

They’re made-to-order in the UK, repairable, and you can even customize a pair with your desired colors, shaft height, and outsole thickness.

Sizing & Fit Type

  • Wide toe box
  • Medium volume, but the lining is so plush that it can be compressed to fit a lot of different volumes
  • True to size, but fits close because of wool lining

The lining on these is VERY thick. They felt quite tight when they were brand new, but over time the wool is tamping down. If you high an extra wide and/or high volume foot you may want to size up.


Wildling Shoes

Leather & Wool | Waterproof | Rated to 10F/-12C | Ships from Germany

Traction Rating: Snow – Good | Ice – Ok

Use code ANYA for €5/$10 off your purchase.

Wildling Shoes released the Feral this year – a new winter friendly boot. They have a felted wool lining, waterproof membrane, and grippy outsole, all while being light and flexible. They also have a wider toe box than you usually find on Wildling boots, but still in their squared off shape for lots of room.

While these are not sufficient to keep me outside for long during the harsh Midwest winters, I am really enjoying them in this late fall weather when it’s cold but not frigid. They are practical and cozy while giving me full foot freedom so I feel secure and grounded. Wildling has other nice wool-lined boots, but the Feral is the most winter friendly.

Sizing & Fit Type

  • Wide width. Will work for some extra wide feet.
  • Plateau/Square shaped
  • Medium to High volume
  • True to size.

If you have low volume feet I highly recommend adding one of Wilding’s wool insoles to your order. Wildlings do intentionally fit long so you have plenty of toe space!


Mukishoes Igneous

Leather | Wool Lined | Rated to 10F/-12C | Ships from EU

Traction Rating: Snow – Good | Ice – Good

Use code ANYAMUKI for 10% off.

The Mukishoes Igneous is a soft boot that looks stylish and on trend while still being delightfully light and flexible. They’re one of my faves! A similar feel to the Shapen Cozy, but with a lighter sole, slimmer toe box and a felted wool lining (instead of fluffy wool). I wear mine with an additional wool insole for warmth (and it helps them fit better on my low arches too).

Also available from Mukishoes is the Lapedo, which is lined with a cotton plush. It’s surprisingly warm and soft (thicker than the Igneous’ lining) and they are adorable. I love both of these for a cute look that I feel like I can really move in.

Sizing & Fit Type

  • Medium width – on the slimmer side compared to other options here.
  • Mountain shaped
  • Medium to high volume
  • True to size, maybe slightly small

Because Mukishoes are not extra wide fitting many people size up for a little extra space. They do fit pretty high volume, so insoles are your friend if you’re low volume.


Softstar Phoenix

Leather | Sheepskin Lined | Rated to -25F/-32C | Ships from USA

Traction Rating: Snow – Good | Ice – Good

The Softstar Phoenix is a fully lined high quality sheepskin boot with a side zipper for easy on and off. The fur is thick without them feeling too tight on my toes. They keep my legs and feet cozy in cold temps, and they’re easy to put on and off!

My one complaint with them is that the heel is wide and slips off when I step, even in thick socks. So they are better suited for people with thicker, wider feet.

Sizing & Fit Type

  • Wide to extra wide width
  • Medium volume over the top of the foot, but room in the ankle and heel area.
  • True to size

Honorable Mentions

Zaqq Quintic

Leather | Wool Lined | Waterproof | Rated to -5F/-20C | Ships from EU

Traction Rating: Snow – Great | Ice – Great

The Zaqq Quintic is so soft, and yet warm and practical. The outsole is grippy so you’re not sliding everywhere, and the waterproof upper means your feet stay dry. Both Justin and I like these boots as a surprisingly warm and functional boot without a heavy sole. They are easier to access for EU folks.

Sizing & Fit Type:

  • Medium to wide width
  • Mountain shaped
  • Medium volume
  • Runs Small

The fur lining is quite thick and so they feel pretty snug in my normal size. I went up one and they still are quite cozy!


Feelgrounds Patrol

Vegan Leather | Waterproof | Rated to 5F / -15C | Ships from EU

Traction Rating: Snow – Great | Ice – Good

Use code ANYASREVIEWS for 15% off

The Feelgrounds Patrol Winter boots have a robust outsole with good traction and a waterproof upper, while still retaining some flexibility. They are also vegan and insulated for warmth. I use them with their optional extra insole for a better fit on my low volume feet.

For me the heel cup is a little stiff (I have a sensitive achilles), but Justin wears his frequently in the winter and they are very practical. Great for someone who wants a durable waterproof barefoot winter boot with a bit more sole.

Sizing & Fit Type

  • Wide to extra wide fit
  • Mountain shaped
  • Medium to high volume
  • Slightly small

In this shoe I recommend sizing up because they run short in our experience.


Manitobah Mukluks

Leather | Faux Fur Lined | Rated to -25F/-32C | Ships from Canada

Traction Rating: Snow – Great | Ice – Good

Manitobah is an Aboriginal-owned Canadian brand that makes faux fur and sheepskin lined mukluks. The original mukluks are built on a super flexible Vibram outsole (but not all models are zero drop, so look for the flat ones!). They are thick and warm inside and yet you still feel grounded. One bonus to Manitobah is that they have waterproof options!

Manitobah tends to fit quite loose through the ankle so I chose this wrap tie version for adjustability. They are the softest, coziest boots! Since the boots I got are not waterproof, I used Nikwax spray on it, which seems to be working well. The photos above are of the Short Wrap boot, which is no longer available but they still have the Tall Wrap.

Sizing & Fit Type

  • Narrow to medium width toe box
  • High volume
  • Runs big/stretches a lot

Manitobah mukluks have a fairly tapered toe box when brand new, but there is a lot of vertical space and the leather stretches out a lot as you wear them. Still not best suited for really wide toes.


Zeazoo Dingo

Leather | Sheepskin lined | Rated to -20F / -29C | Ships from EU

Traction Rating: Snow – Good | Ice – Good

The Zeazoo Dingo is a personal favorite of mine. They are the perfect barefoot Uggs dupe and so easy to slip on for quick jaunts outside when it’s freezing. I wear mine often as school-run, coffee-run, and mail-run shoes. The sheepskin lining wicks sweat so they’re comfortable barefoot and they are just so warm but lighter than all the above options (and nice and wide). You can also roll the top down to get a furry cuff and a shorter height.

While they are a home run for warmth, they don’t have a robust outsole so the bottom edges of the boot can start wearing quickly if you use them roughly. And the upper is not water resistant. They’re more of a warm ultra-light lifestyle boot than an active outdoor snow boot. Still, a total lifesaver if you live in a cold climate.

Sizing & Fit Type

  • Medium width
  • Plateau shaped
  • Medium volume
  • Runs big

I size down in the Dingo and still have plenty of space! The cozy fur lining also tamps down with use so it’s ok if they feel snug when brand new. Once worn in they can be a little loose on thin ankles and narrow heels, so leg warmers are a great way to make the Dingo work for low volume feet.


Magical Shoes Alaskan

Leather | Wool Lined | Rated to 25F/-4C | Ships from Poland

Traction Rating: Snow – Good | Ice – Great

Use code ANYA for 10% off

The Magical Shoes Alaskan is an ultra flexible, ultra lightweight wool-lined barefoot winter boot. The outsole is very grippy on snow and ice, and the side zipper makes them easy to put on and off. For being so light, they are surprisingly practical. But I do find the material on the thinner side so my feet got cold faster than in the other boots I tested. I put in an extra insole and warm socks, but still felt the cold through the top fairly quickly in my climate.

While the upper material is water resistant, the stitching, zipper and the tongue is not waterproof so water can come through pretty easily if soaked.

Sizing & Fit Type

  • Medium to wide width
  • Plateau shaped toe box
  • Medium to high volume
  • Runs small

I definitely recommend sizing up in these, especially if you have wide feet!


Share This Post:

Tagged:

Subscribe to the Barefoot Shoe Digest™

Stay up to date on all the best shoes, current sales, newest releases, and more

You May Also Like:

Comments

298 thoughts on “The All Time Warmest Barefoot Winter Boots for Snow”

  1. Hi Anya – thanks for this comprehensive list! I live in Minnesota (for context about the weather) and I’m comparing the Xero Shoes Alpine Snow Boot and the Lems Breck Boot insulated. I’m a big fan of Lems and use my Boulder boots a ton, but I guess I’m concerned about the traction and tread? I know you rated both the Alpine and Breck as good for ice, but would you have a preference between the two? (I’m okay with the Breck not being zero-drop). Thanks so much in advance!

    1. If you are used to the original Lems Boulder boot, the Breck has MUCH better traction. I personally don’t recommend the Lems Boulder for any kind of inclement weather, but the Boulder Boot Grip, Breck, and many of their other boots are built on a much more functional outdoor sole. Between the Breck and the Xero Alpine I would say the Breck is better on ice, though they are similar.

  2. Hi! I have a pair of Xero Alpin boots and I find that the soles are too stiff, causing pain in my left foot. I was wondering if the Alpine Pull On has a more flexible sole? I have a worn out pair of Xero Makias but they don’t make them any more. Any other suggestions for a warm boot with a flexible sole? I was considering the Manitoba Mukluks but they don’t look like they have a big enough toe box. Thanks!

  3. Hi Anya,
    Your review was excellent and super helpful! I’m looking at getting my first pair of barefoot boots, and I don’t have any experience with sizing. I measured my foot with the book, and it’s 89mm at the widest point. I want to get a pair of Steger Mukluks, and their 8W insole is exactly 89mm. The 8WW is 95. Which one would you recommend I go with here?
    Thanks!

    1. Sorry to dosagree but when you live fulltime in ice and snow , there is nothing that compares to Steger Mukluks , made by hand in our remote nortĥern town for arctic explorers . Nothing compares !! ♥️

  4. Thanks for keeping this list updated! I wear truly barefoot shoes daily and for activities, but I have really cold feet (Reynauds) and I need a warm winter boot for times when I am standing around outside. The bottoms of my feet get cold and turn bad colors in standard barefoot shoes because the soles are so thin. A liner is not enough.. Sadly, I think I need some serious space between my foot and the ground. We get a lot of weird up and down weather in my area. For example, it is 15F today but the streams are still running. So I prefer the boot to be waterproof, at least on the bottom portion. I have a narrow heal and softer boots tend to slip down. I am considering Mukluks with waterproof spray. How terrible will those boots be, considering I am used to barefoot shoes? The Tundra Esc caught my eye, but they are not waterproof, and I just can’t spend that much if the shoe does not do *everything*. I also read that people’s feet slip in the Tundra Esc because of the way the ankle is laced. I like that both of those options come up high on the leg, although I suppose this is not a dealbreaker. What can you recommend for me?

    1. Curious what you’ve found and liked. I live near Calgary with both cold weather and Chinooks also have Reynaud’s. I’ve worn Manitobah mukluks. Historically my feet ran narrow, but not sure about my heels specifically. I do have a bunion on one foot. I’ve been transitioning towards more barefoot. The MM’s aren’t quite as warm as I might wish for. I might try my thicker wool socks with them this year and see if that helps. I don’t usually have trouble with the spasms wearing them, but my feet so feel chilly at times in our coldest weather, especially riding on the car. Ha, I wonder if I should try a heating pad under my feet for that. I will say they have always kept my feet dry and I haven’t added extra waterproof spray. I’ve wondered if Xero or something what might be warmer.

      1. I found Steger mukluks and the Vivo Tundra Esc to be considerably warmer than Manitobah Mukluks. Also the Xero Alpine Pull-On is really warm everywhere, but not quite as thick and warm in the sole. So I would recommend putting in a felted wool or sheepskin insole to make them warmer.

        1. Thank you! Do you find the original (not pull on) Xero alpine boots to be warmer than Manitobah mukluks? My MM’s aren’t roomy enough to at an insole, but maybe the Xero Alpine’s would. Or maybe they wouldn’t need it with a thicker sole…

          1. No, I found the pull on boots to be the warmer model by a good bit! The Alpines are quite roomy and in the midfoot too.

    2. I have super cold feet even though I don’t have Reynauds. I work outside several days a week, and on concrete. I first got Solerunner Transition 3 Varios – wide enough, but really not significantly insulated. Pretty close to true barefoot.

      BeLenka Arctic Edge was my next attempt and definitely better. A smidge more sole thickness, more insulated for sure, but a pretty sloped shape which, when I broke my 5th metatarsal summer ’25 I found my still swollen foot was pretty uncomfortable in them.

      So third time was treat, Barebarics Arctic Edge, one size up. High volume so good for really thick socks, a squarer shape so better on my pinkies, waterproof and a thicker sole than the BeLenkas. Possibly warmer even than my previous full on snow boots (Vaude, LandsEnd and Salomon over the years) that all had 400g Thinsulate.

      I have retired my heated socks! Not a snow boot as not tall, but might work for you (maybe with added gaiters for snow? No idea if that works!).

  5. Is there such a thing as a barefoot-shaped ski boot? I can’t find one that doesn’t warp my toe position in the toe box.

  6. Thank you, Anya. I ordered a Xero Alpine Pull-On. This seems to be an answer to prayer because I was concerned many of the popular brands would squish my feet. I prefer “barefoot” zero drop shoes and sandals, and had no idea there were boots. I had a pair of clunky snow boots for probably about 20 years, and they just “died” because the treads came off. I also ordered some socks to go with these boots and some cowboy boots I bought previously. I copied the link to this page in my Notepad. Very helpful.

  7. I was chatting with Manitobah and they’re saying all their shoes are zero drop now! They said: There were some a season or two ago that had some arch support but they have since been discontinued for some time now.

  8. Hello.
    I need help choosing the right size, as I’m new to this. I have a pair of Ohne Project 080 sneakers in size 38 EU, and they fit perfectly. Now I want to buy my first pair of boots and I’ve chosen the Belenka Winter 3.0. I’m not sure whether to get size 38 or 39 EU. My foot measurements are: Right foot: length 23.5 cm, width 9.5 cm
    Left foot: length 23.3 cm, width 9 cm
    Could you help me with the size?

    Thank you very much

    1. Hello Patricia, I would choose a size EU 39 for lined winter boots. Most people size up 1 from their sneaker size for winter boots.

  9. Thanks, I gathered the pull on are the warmer of the two Xero models, but do you think the classic Xero still warmer than Manitobah Mukluks?

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Picture of Hi. I'm Anya.

Hi. I'm Anya.

I first discovered barefoot shoes after a long history of foot issues. By changing my footwear and strengthening my body I was able to completely transform my life. Anya’s Reviews is my way of sharing with the world that healthy feet are happy feet!

Follow Me

Subscribe for weekly updates

Check out our shop!

Shoe Finder

Popular Posts

Archives
Scroll to Top

Thank you for subscribing!

So I can serve you better, can you answer this one quick question?

What is the #1 thing I can help you with?

Subscribe to the Barefoot Shoe Digest™

Stay up to date on all the best shoes, current sales, newest releases, and more.